How does the standard review work?

Even3 has two reviewing options: standard and criteria.

To know more about the criteria review, check out the article Como funciona a avaliação de trabalhos por critérios?

In this article, you'll learn how the standard work review works!

First of all, you need to know that the evaluation done by Even3 is double-blind. In other words, the authors don't know who the reviewers are and the reviewers don't know who the authors are.

Learn more! For a better understanding, please know the importance of double-blind review.

How does the standard review work

In the standard review, the reviewers will be able to give three types of rating:

• Approved
• Rejected
• Approved with reservations

What happens if one reviewer rates one work as Approved and the other one, rates it not Approved? 

The work will automatically be sent to a third reviewer.

How does Approval with reservations work?

Approval with reservations works as follows: If a work is approved with reservations, it will be available for the authors to submit the corrected work. As soon as the author submits the correction, the work goes back to the reviewer who gave the assessment, and the reviewer can approve or not.

The option to approve with reservations is optional. You can enable this option or not.

The participant can only submit a correction if the work is approved with reservations.

Activating standard review

Access the Submissions menu, submenu Review

Go to the Settings tab

Change the type of review to standard

Choose if the review will have the option Approval with  reservations or not

Now what? Now that you already know how the standard review works, learn how automatic and manual distributions work.